Baxter spent one postgraduate season at Hargrave Military Academy alongside Korleone Young, the Detroit Pistons' 1998 NBA draft choice. Scouts filled the bleachers to watch Young play, but Williams was one of the few with his eyes drawn to the skilled big man. Many others didn't view Baxter as an ACC caliber player. He was undersized and overweight at the time.
"Those guys wore military uniforms every day," Williams said. "They had to get up very early in the morning, all those things. I think that really helped Lonny become a very disciplined basketball player. He was one of those guys I knew when he came in would work hard, and he certainly did that, reaching an incredible level as a college basketball player."
Baxter, a 6-foot-8, 260-pound big man, did what Williams hoped and made an immediate impact at Maryland in 1998-99. He was an Honorable Mention All-ACC freshman team selection and promptly produced iconic moments. Against North Texas on Dec. 23, 1998, Baxter set the school record for best-single game shooting performance. He went 10-for-10, also tying the school record for most consecutive field goals made in a game.
The freshman later started 10 of the team's final 11 games after fellow big man Obinna Ekezie suffered a season-ending injury. Baxter was thrust into the mix and helped his team achieve an NCAA Tournament Sweet 16 berth for the fourth time in six years.
As a sophomore in 1999-2000, Baxter was one of just two players to start all 35 games for the Terps. He led the ACC in offensive rebounds (3.6), ranked second in field goal percentage (.533) and rebounds (8.8) and placed third with 2.3 blocks per game. Baxter also posted his first 30-point performance with a 31-point outing against NC State on Feb. 6, 2000.