After becoming a state champion at Octarara High School in his junior and senior years, Letts developed into a nationally top-ranked recruit. His wrestling journey led him to College Park, initially partly because of his desire to escape the Commonwealth.
"I just had to get out of the state," Letts said. "That was kind of the initial thought. Wanting to leave the state was big."
Upon arriving in College Park for his first recruiting visit, Letts was impressed with the coaching staff and facilities. As he began getting to know his new teammates, he knew he was meant to be a Terp.
Once the season started, Letts began to succeed immediately on the mat.
In 2006-07 — Letts' freshman season — he was ranked as high as No. 10 in the nation for his weight class, finishing tied for the team lead in wins. He posted a 31-7 record, leading the team with 10 major decisions and four technical falls. The freshman went undefeated in ACC action and won the ACC Championship at 174 pounds. Letts became the first true freshman to advance to the NCAA Tournament since 1990.
There, he won two matches, bringing to a close an incredibly successful freshman campaign. But for Letts, all the early accolades and success were not enough. Even as a freshman, the stink of losing at NCAAs left a bad taste in his mouth.
"You're like, 'Wait, all these guys are still wrestling, and I'm not in the mix?'" he recalls. "I was happy to be having success. … But I was also pissed immediately following losing."
This lousy feeling gave Letts extra motivation, and he proceeded to post a 100-21 record in his next four seasons.