All-Americans
| Name | Year | Event |
| Ron Squiers | 1963 | Diving |
| Phil Denkevitz | 1965 | Freestyle |
| Kirk Sanocki | 1985 | Breaststroke |
| Mike Lambert | 1988 | Individual Medley |
| 1988 | Individual Medley | |
| Mike Noonan | 1991 | Diving |
| 1992 | Diving | |
| Kevin Burke | 1998 | Diving |
Footer
| Name | Year | Event |
| Ron Squiers | 1963 | Diving |
| Phil Denkevitz | 1965 | Freestyle |
| Kirk Sanocki | 1985 | Breaststroke |
| Mike Lambert | 1988 | Individual Medley |
| 1988 | Individual Medley | |
| Mike Noonan | 1991 | Diving |
| 1992 | Diving | |
| Kevin Burke | 1998 | Diving |