| Year |
Recipient |
| 2023 |
Tasha Brozowski (Gymnastics) |
| 2022 |
Ryan Blumberg (Men's Soccer) |
| 2021 |
Grace Zeckowski (Track & Field) |
| 2020 |
None* |
| 2019 |
Youssif Hemida (Wrestling) |
| 2018 |
Billy Phillips (Baseball) |
| 2017 |
Will Likely III (Football) |
| 2016 |
Cody Niedermeier (Men's Soccer) |
| 2015 |
Dez Wells (Men's Basketball) |
| 2014 |
Jessie Black (Gymnastics) |
| 2013 |
Josh Asper (Wrestling) |
| Prior to 2013 the Silvester Watch was presented to the athlete who typified the best in college athletics |
| 2012 |
Megan Frazer (Field Hockey) |
| 2011 |
Grant Catalino (Men's Lacrosse) |
| 2010 |
Eric Hayes (Men's Basketball) |
|
Brian Phipps (Men's Lacrosse) |
|
Kevin Tangney (Men's Soccer) |
| 2009 |
Hudson Taylor (Wrestling) |
| 2008 |
Stephen King (Men's Soccer) |
| 2007 |
Maurice Edu (Men's Soccer) |
| 2006 |
Jason Garey (Men's Soccer) |
| 2005 |
Jason Garey (Men's Soccer) |
| 2004 |
Seth Stammler (Men's Soccer) |
| 2003 |
E.J. Henderson (Football) |
| 2002 |
Lonny Baxter (Men's Basketball) |
| 2001 |
Terence Morris (Men's Basketball) |
| 2000 |
Larry Long (Baseball) |
| 1999 |
Obinna Ekezie (Men's Basketball) |
| 1998 |
Leo Cullen (Men's Soccer) |
| 1997 |
Scott Grayson (Men's Soccer) |
| 1996 |
Jermaine Lewis (Football) |
| 1995 |
Jamie Bragg (Football) |
| 1994 |
Geoff Wilcox (Men's Swimming & Diving) |
| 1993 |
Steve Woods (Wrestling) |
| 1992 |
Derek Hacopian (Baseball) |
| 1991 |
Kurt Kendall (Men's Swimming & Diving) |
| 1990 |
William J. Meury (Baseball) |
| 1989 |
Phil Willard (Men's Swimming & Diving) |
| 1988 |
Michael Lambert (Men's Swimming & Diving) |
| 1987 |
Ted Chapman (Football) |
| 1986 |
Dennis Cullinane (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1985 |
Eric Wilson (Football) |
| 1984 |
Norman "Boomer" Esiason (Football) |
| 1983 |
David Pacella (Football) |
| 1982 |
Anthony Larioni (Baseball) |
| 1981 |
Gregory Manning (Men's Basketball) |
| 1980 |
James Shaffer (Football) |
| 1979 |
Gregory Robinson (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1978 |
Brian Melly (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1977 |
Joseph Campbell (Football) |
| 1976 |
John Lucas (Men's Basketball/Tennis) |
| 1975 |
Randy White (Football) |
| 1974 |
Tom McMillen (Men's Basketball) |
| 1973 |
Robert Bodell (Men's Basketball) |
| 1972 |
Richard Bendell (Men's Golf) |
| 1971 |
N/A |
| 1970 |
N/A |
| 1969 |
N/A |
| 1968 |
N/A |
| 1967 |
Frank Costello (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1966 |
N/A |
| 1965 |
N/A |
| 1964 |
Richard Shiner (Football) |
| 1963 |
Raymond Altman (Men's Lacrosse) |
| 1962 |
Clayton Beardmore (Men's Lacrosse) |
| 1961 |
Dale Betty (Football) |
| 1960 |
James Joyce (Football) |
| 1959 |
Thomas Tait (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1958 |
Edward Cooke (Football/Track & Field) |
| 1957 |
Burr Grim (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1956 |
Charles Wicker (Men's Lacrosse) |
| 1955 |
Burke Wilson (Men's Track & Field) |
| 1954 |
Martin Crystzer (Football) |
| 1953 |
Paul Nestor (Football) |
| 1932 |
James Johnson (Men's Basketball) |
| 1951 |
Elmer Wingate (Football) |
| 1950 |
Joseph Tucker (Football) |
| 1949 |
Victor Turyn (Football) |
| 1948 |
George Simler (Football) |
| 1947 |
Thomas Mont (Football) |
| 1946 |
Jack Flynt ( |
| 1945 |
N/A |
| 1944 |
N/A |
| 1943 |
N/A |
| 1942 |
Ralph Burlin (Football) |
| 1941 |
Robert Smith (Football) |
| 1940 |
George Lawrence (Football) |
| 1939 |
Edwin Johnson (Baseball/Men's Basketball) |
| 1938 |
William Wolfe (Football) |
| 1937 |
John Gormley (Football) |
| 1936 |
Louis Ennis (Football) |
| 1935 |
John W. Guckeyson (Football/Men's Basketball/Baseball/Track & Field) |
| 1934 |
Norwood Sothoron (Football/Men's Basketball/Men's Lacrosse/Baseball) |
| 1933 |
Albert Woods (Football) |
| 1932 |
George Chalmers (Football/Men's Basketball/Baseball) |
| 1931 |
Louis Berger (Football/Men's Basketball/Baseball) |
| 1930 |
William Evans (Football/Men's Basketball/Men's Lacrosse) |
|
Albert Heagy (Football/Men's Basketball/Men's Lacrosse) |
| 1929 |
Gordon Kessler (Football) |
| 1928 |
Lewis Thomas (Football) |
| 1927 |
Myron Stevens (Baseball/Men's Basketball/Football) |
| 1926 |
William Supplee (Baseball/Football) |
| 1925 |
Joseph Burger (Men's Basketball/Football/Men's Lacrosse) |
| 1924 |
Thomas McQuade (Football/Men's Lacrosse) |
| 1923 |
George Pollock (Football) |
| 1922 |
Harry Semler (Baseball/Football) |
| 1921 |
Andrew Nisbit (Football) |
